Full Picture

Article analysis:

The article "The Cluster as Market Organisation" by Peter Maskell and Mark Lorenzen explores the concept of clusters as a spatial configuration of the economy suitable for the creation, transfer, and usage of knowledge. The authors investigate how rent-seeking firms build network relations to create knowledge and obtain resource efficiency while keeping transaction costs at bay. They also consider the cluster as an emerging, self-organizing alternative for interfirm relationships in cases where global network formation becomes a less feasible strategy.

The article provides a comprehensive overview of the concept of clusters and their potential advantages for firms. However, there are some potential biases in the article that need to be considered. For example, the authors focus on industries where clustering might be considered superior to other forms of market organization, which could lead to one-sided reporting. Additionally, some claims made in the article lack evidence or exploration of counterarguments.

One potential bias is that the authors only investigate industries where clustering might be considered superior to other forms of market organization. This could lead to one-sided reporting because it ignores industries where clustering may not be advantageous or even detrimental. For example, in highly competitive industries with low barriers to entry, clustering may lead to increased competition and lower profits for firms.

Another potential bias is that some claims made in the article lack evidence or exploration of counterarguments. For example, when discussing relation-specific sunk costs as a safeguard against opportunistic behavior, the authors do not explore potential drawbacks such as reduced flexibility or increased risk aversion.

Despite these potential biases, the article provides valuable insights into the concept of clusters and their potential advantages for firms. The authors provide empirical evidence from two industries - pop music and furniture - demonstrating how clustering can lead to increased knowledge creation and resource efficiency. They also discuss how clusters can provide an environment that curtails costs and risks associated with establishing new firms through relocation or spin-offs.

In conclusion, while there are some potential biases in "The Cluster as Market Organisation," the article provides valuable insights into the concept of clusters and their potential advantages for firms. However, readers should be aware of these biases and consider other perspectives when evaluating the benefits and drawbacks of clustering in different industries.