Full Picture

Article analysis:

The article "Exploring the development of students’ identities as educational leaders and educational researchers in a professional practice doctoral program" presents an interesting study on how students in an EdD program develop their identities as educational leaders and researching professionals. The article is well-structured, with clear objectives and a thorough literature review that contextualizes the research.

However, there are some potential biases in the article that need to be addressed. Firstly, the use of "researching professionals" instead of "educational researchers" may indicate a bias towards practical research rather than theoretical research. This bias is further reinforced by the focus on preparing students with researching skills appropriate to conduct research in their practice settings that were relevant to their on-going efforts.

Secondly, while the article acknowledges earlier work on identity development, it does not explore counterarguments or alternative perspectives. For example, while Erikson's theory of identity development is mentioned briefly, there is no discussion of criticisms or limitations of this theory.

Thirdly, the article makes unsupported claims about how possible selves theory might account for the development of identities as educational leaders and researching professionals. While this theory is relevant to identity development, it is not clear how it specifically applies to these particular identities.

Finally, there are missing points of consideration in the article. For example, there is no discussion of potential risks associated with developing strong identities as educational leaders or researching professionals. Additionally, there is no exploration of how these identities might interact with other aspects of students' lives or how they might change over time.

Overall, while the article presents an interesting study on identity development in an EdD program, there are potential biases and missing points of consideration that need to be addressed for a more balanced analysis.